So I recently moved away from the iPhone 3G to a Palm Pre, and as a result from AT&T to Sprint. This is something that I never thought would happen but the more time goes by the better I feel about it. To start with, AT&T's 3G service is a complete joke unless you're in the middle of nowhere and that place happens to have 3G service which are usually mutually exclusive. Why you ask? Because AT&T's network is oversaturated with all the new iPhone users hungry for data.
There were many times when I would have a full 5 bars of 3G but the internet would be ridiculously slow to the point where it was useless. Then there were times where the much touted Visual Voicemail was a complete failure and I would get voicemail notifications hours after people left them.
It seems since I left AT&T, things are getting worse, no doubt because of all the new iPhone 3GS customers jumping on top of the already strained network. As TechCrunch stated in a recent blog post, AT&T sucks big time.
While Sprint has its share of problems
, the one thing they do have going for them is that their data network, well, it actually works! The best way to quantify this is the fact that while I had the iPhone 3G on AT&T, the most data I ever used in a month was about 50MB. On Sprint, this month alone (and I still have a week left before the the next cycle), I'm already at 1,650MB. Sure, I could have used that much data on the iPhone but in order to do it, I'd have to have put up with AT&T's crappy data network and by the time stuff loaded I would have probably poked my eyes out with sharp pencils.
So what's the solution? From what I've heard any other carrier except AT&T including Verizon, Sprint and T-Mobile haven't completely dropped the ball with their data network and there's actually a possibility you can make use of your fancy 3G smartphone whenever and however you want. While I'm still shocked to some degree I went from the #1 US wireless carrier to #3, the benefits are really starting to pay off.
Some other differences include less dropped calls on Sprint (even in bad coverage) than AT&T. Many times with AT&T I'd be sitting pretty with 5 bars of 3G and have a dropped call for no apparent reason. My wife still has an iPhone 3G and sees this occasionally, as do members of my family. I think it's blatantly obvious that AT&T's network needs an upgrade on the backend and not just the towers. They just recently upgraded the towers in my area so there's always 5 bars of 3G ("most bars in most places") but what good is that when the damn service is unreliable and doesn't work half the time?!
Notice I didn't mention anything about devices per se, and compare the iPhone 3G to the Palm Pre since I think that's just personal preference. Both are excellent devices depending on what you want. At the end of the day, devices are extremely important in deciding what carrier I use but the reality is...devices can only be as good as the network they are on